Dec 8, 2020
For a taste of Italy in Indiana, look no further than a pizzeria local to Fishers, IN. The following six choices include delicious choices with roots from Italy to India, desserts and drinks to elevate the meal, and the very best pizza in Fishers. 
Best Pizza in Fishers, IN: 6 Fantastic Local Pizzerias
1. Passione
A visit to Passione may leave you thinking you’ve exited Indiana and entered the Italian countryside. The pizzeria promises authentic Italian cuisine cooked to order in Pavesi wood fire ovens and paired with top-notch red wines.
If you’re not a pizza fan, they offer some of the best wings in Fishers, which are deep-fried, covered in sauce, and cooked in the oven for optimal caramelization. Round of the meal with cannolis or gelato for the full Italian experience.
2. Chicago Pizza With a Twist
The best slice starts with an optimal crust, and you’re sure to find one at Chicago with a Twist. The traditional deep-dish Chicago pizza won’t disappoint, but if you’re in the mood for something new, the Naan crust is a terrific canvas for your toppings.
Even better than the pies are the desserts, which include dessert pizzas after your entree slices, cakey balls of fried milk known as gulab jaman, and rasmalai, a classic Indian dessert made with milk and saffron,
3. Aurelio’s
A fan favorite since 1959, Aurelio’s offers a sense of familiar comfort from a chain that started off as a single-family pizzeria. With over a dozen available ingredients to customize your slice, you’re sure to find your new favorite combo.
Additionally, keep an eye out for the original Italian submarine sandwich, bruschetta, zucchini sticks, Mama Aurelio’s spinach calabrese, and the signature stuffed crust pizzas.
4. Pearl Street Pizzeria & Pub
With a brand new Fishers location, Pearl Street Pizzeria & Pub is a fresh and exciting joint poised to become your go-to restaurant. Unlike other pizzeria’s Pearl Street offers customizable calzones so you can enjoy your favorite toppings in a different format.
Innovative signature slices, such as a Mexican option with chorizo and jalapenos or the Pear & Gorgonzola with Bartlett pears and fresh arugula, are a sure win.
5. Puccini’s Pizza & Pasta
By far the most extensive menu, Puccini’s is sure to have an option for everyone, whether you’re vegetarian, gluten-free, low carb, or all of the above.
With over fifty toppings to customize, it may be tempting not to venture further down the menu, but you risk missing out on signature combos such as Cactus Delectus, Bama Jam, or Campfire, the winner of the best classic pizza in America. Desserts, such as the chocolate torte or NYC deli cheesecake, are a must.
6. Noble Roman’s Craft Pizza & Pub
The very best of all other options, from quality crust to over forty toppings, can be found at Noble Roman’s. Their dough is made from scratch using King Arthur brand flour in a glass-enclosed and climate control room, before being pressed into Deep-Dish Sicilian molds and topped with sauce from vine-ripened tomatoes.
A free valet service that brings your food to your car, as well as the bar with over 29 beers and 16 wine, earn Noble Roman’s its spot on this list.
Your worldwide cuisine tour starts at one of the local pizzerias in Fishers. After sampling the best of the city, take a trip to Ed Martin Nissan of Fishers for anything and everything relating to vehicles!
Connect with us
Recent Blog Entries
- Three Reasons Drivers Choose the 2025 Nissan Z
- Exploring the Trim Levels of the 2025 Nissan LEAF: Electric Driving Customized
- Introducing the 2025 Nissan Murano: Elegance on Wheels
- Understanding the Trim Levels of the 2025 Nissan Armada: Space and Luxury Your Way
- The Class-Leading Features of the 2025 Nissan Frontier